Share This Article with a Friend!

How Many Immigrants Are Enough?

According to a recently released Department of Homeland Security report, during the past three years for which statistics are available (2012 to 2014) the United States has allowed entry to an average of over 1 million legal immigrants per year. 

During the same time the real wages of American production and nonsupervisory workers have been stagnant, hovering well below $700 per week – far below their $827 peak back in the early 1970s. 

Immigrants and welfareIt would be easy to blame this situation on the entry of foreign guest workers under such programs as the H-1B visa program that led to the firings at Disney’s Florida operation that Marco Rubio defended and then figured so prominently in Rubio’s defeat in the presidential primary in his home state. 

But the majority of legal immigrants are not admitted through so-called employment-based preferences, they are admitted through chain-migration or the so-called family reunification policies that led to the admission of 1,976,122 immigrants to America during those three years. 

Employment-based preferences accounted for only 14 percent of the legal immigrants admitted each of those years and we think the strong case can be made that it is not the specific categories, but the sheer volume of immigrants that has been a major contributor to the economic and quality of life disaster that has befallen America’s middle income citizens over the past 40 years. 

Every one of those newly admitted immigrants represents a new demand on America’s schools, roads, hospitals and other public services by someone who has contributed zero to funding them. 

At the same time that this massive influx of immigrants creates downward pressure on wages it also creates upward pressure on the housing market and taxpayer funded services.  

It may be a win – win for big business that benefits from lower wages and an increased demand for its products, but it is lose – lose for America’s citizen workers and their families. 

And as our friends Daniel Horowitz and Phyllis Schlafly have documented, it has vast political consequences as well. 

Almost 20 percent of those receiving green cards in 2014 reside in California.  Roughly 60 percent reside in one of the following five states: California, New York, Florida, Texas, and New Jersey.  At this pace, it will be hard for Republicans to remain competitive in Florida.  And Texas will continue its slow march to becoming a purple state, noted Horowitz in a recent article for Conservative Review

And as Mrs. Schlafly pointed out in an incisive article for Townhall, “The current level of legal immigration to America adds thousands of people every day whose views and experience are contrary to the conservative value of limited government…” 

Mrs. Schlafly documented that “An enormous body of survey research shows that large majorities of recent immigrants, who are mostly Hispanic and Asian, hold liberal views on most policy issues and therefore vote Democratic two-to-one. Their motivation is not our immigration policy; it is economic issues. 

“The 2008 National Annenberg Election Survey found that 62 percent of immigrants prefer a single government-run health care system. The 2010 Cooperative Congressional Election Study found that 69 percent of immigrants support Obamacare, and the Pew Research Center found that 75 percent of Hispanic and 55 percent of Asian immigrants support bigger government.” 

It is also worth noting a Harris poll Mrs. Schlafly cites that “found that 81 percent of native-born Americans believe the schools should teach students to be proud of being American, compared to only 50 percent of immigrants who had become naturalized U.S. citizens. Only 37 percent of naturalized citizens (compared to 67 percent of native-born citizens) think our Constitution has a higher legal authority than international law. 

The Pew Research Center reported in 2011 that, of all groups surveyed, Hispanics have the most negative view of capitalism in America -- 55 percent. This is even higher than the supporters of Occupy Wall Street.” 

Heather MacDonald of the Manhattan Institute has also studied the views of new immigrants and concluded that, "It is not immigration policy that creates the strong bond between Hispanics and the Democratic Party, but the core Democratic principles of a more generous safety net, strong government intervention in the economy, and progressive taxation." 

The current level of immigration, even without amnesty, will add nearly 15 million new potential voters by 2036, a large share of whom will favor the left. To allow this to happen will make Republicans and conservatives a permanent political minority. 

Since 1970 the foreign-born population of the United States has increased 324.5 percent and American incomes have declined

This is not just some conservative fantasy: in 2015 the respected non-partisan Congressional Research Service has just released a study showing “Wages Declined As Immigration Surged” and what the study shows is wages and share of income for the bottom 90 percent of American wage-earners declined over the past 40 years, as the foreign-born population increased dramatically. 

But just as bad, if not worse, than the economic effects of the vast tide of illegal and legal immigration is our failure to assimilate them. And these unassimilated immigrants, most from Third World countries, are the “shock troops” of Barack Obama’s far-left progressive plan to fundamentally transform America. 

The vast tide of legal and illegal immigrants flowing into America amounts to a population replacement program in which believers in American exceptionalism and the values protected by the Constitution are being replaced with potential clients of the progressive welfare state – and I might add voters who are almost certain to vote Democratic. 

We urge you to call your Congressman and Senators to demand a freeze on most legal immigration. The Capitol switchboard is 1-866-220-0044, please call today.

Share this

How many are too many?

Answer: first, remove/deport all illegal aliens, starting with foreign student Obama (this would be about 25 million) add another 25 million by restricting immigration for say 10 years, and that would be a start. And the time to start is NOW.

How Many Immigrants Are Enough?

This article is cause for much thought. I am 2d generation mainland (NYC) of Puerto Rican ancestry, although my island born mom was also born a US Citizen. The effects of downward wage pressures on especially entry level and blue collar incomes does NOT concern me as much as it does the author, because I believe there are far more serious causes for this pressure. (e.g. corporate tax rates driving manufacturers offshore, overregulation (especially environmental, etc.). I do not disagree with the author, but one area where I am in concerned agreement is the idea that: "Hispanics have the most negative view of capitalism in America -- 55 percent. This is even higher than the supporters of Occupy Wall Street.” I have been blessed to have grown up at a time that American Exceptionalism was taught and lived even in the most hardscrabble of NYC neighborhoods. The philosophy of many there was that they would kill themselves working so that their children won't have to. If one adult could not afford to rent an apartment, then offer to a relative or friend to rent a bedroom and we'll all survive. And we did it without Section 8 or Social Security Disability. The concept that only in America can one come with pocket change and make yourself a millionaire is no longer taught in our schools or seen in our first generation neighborhoods. As I enter my retirement years, I'd like to contribute my time to see if the idea of America being so Exceptional can happen again. If that doesn't happen soon even the complete suspension of legal immigration will be too little, too late!

Illegal aliens

The subservience of members of congress to their group cowardice in protecting the United States from both internal enemies and external enemies is starting to build an undercurrent of major dissatisfaction among the people, and dire results for them may be in the offing if they don't make a turn-around very soon.
All of the patriots did not live in only the 18th and 19th centuries.


In the past, immigrants came to America for American values and to achieve the American dream. Today, too many immigrants come to America for the generosity of the American taxpayer and to destroy the American dream.


In a word: yes.

How many immigrants are enough

Wrong question. The correct question is how many are too many.
We have too many immigrants when the pundits say they (immigrants) are the fastest growing population.
We have too many immigrants when we had to begin to print government documents in multiple languages. Has anyone figured out how much that costs the American taxpayers?
We have too many immigrants when we can't figure out where they are.
We have too many immigrants when they decide they have the right to march down the street carrying their homeland flag and demanding the same rights as American citizens.
We have too many immigrants when they feel it is not necessary to assimilate into American culture.
In short on this day, Friday, 15 March 16 we have too many immigrants and should halt all immigration until we can right our ship.