Share This Article with a Friend!


Is the FOX News Decision to Let Gary Johnson into Orlando Debate Just Good Theater?

Former New Mexico Governor Gary Johnson’s somewhat quixotic campaign for the Republican presidential nomination got a boost when FOX News announced he met the criteria for inclusion in the Thursday, September 22, Orlando debate.

Fox News included Johnson at the first debate of the season, in South Carolina in May, but not in the debate it hosted just before the Ames Straw Poll in Iowa. CNN and the Tea Party Express did not include Johnson in the recent debate they hosted in Tampa either.

Johnson, a Libertarian-oriented candidate, has struggled to find a niche in the shadow of the much better known Libertarian-backed candidacy of Congressman Ron Paul. Consequently, he is often not included in the very polls the networks use to determine who qualifies for a spot on the debate stage, creating a cycle that, by Johnson’s calculation, had seemingly guaranteed his exclusion.

Now FOX has tweaked their rules and Governor Johnson is back in.

Johnson, who is probably best known for his calls to legalize marijuana, said in an interview with POLITICO that if he was invited to participate in the FOX debate he did not plan to make a “spectacle,” but concentrate on selling his campaign themes.

In that same interview with POLITICO Johnson outlined his campaign themes as, “I’m promising to submit a balanced budget in 2013. I am promising to veto spending legislation that exceeds revenue. I am promising to overhaul the tax code, that means throwing out the entire federal tax system and replacing it with the fair tax.”

That Governor Johnson does not plan on making a “spectacle” probably comes as somewhat of a disappointment to the FOX marketing department executives in charge of promoting the Thursday evening debate.

With nine candidates on the stage, it remains to be seen whether or not the fall marathon of Republican debates soon proves to be too much for voters. If FOX only added Gary Johnson to Thursday’s line-up to add a little theater to the debate, Libertarians will no doubt enjoy the irony if he sticks to his word not to make a spectacle and shows-up second tier debate regulars like former Utah Governor Jon Huntsman and former Pennsylvania Senator Rick Santorum.

Good for FOX

It reflects well on FOX that the network has recognized Gov. Gary Johnson (no relation) is every bit as much a credible candidate as Jon Huntsman or Rick Santorum. Whatever inspired the change at central casting -- one assumes heavy lobbying from Judge Andrew Napolitano -- Johnson will be motivated to outshine other second-tier candidates. Despite his vulnerability on social issues, he lacks the intense opposition of fellow Libertarian Ron Paul and will be a forceful advocate for deep spending cuts. 

He could own a potent issue if he emphasizes the savings Americans would enjoy by allowing our allies to provide their own defense. Ending our outdated defense of West Germany from the looming threat of Bolshevik invasion would harm neither our solvency nor our security. (I wrote about his proposal here.)

The governor's performance will determine his success, but traditional conservatives should be grateful that another candidate is calling for reducing the size, limiting the scope, and constricting the role of the federal govenment to bring it closer to that envisioned by the Founding Fathers.